Experts Caution Against Using Air Fryers Instead of Ovens — What It Means for Your Favorite Recipes
In recent years, air fryers have become the go-to gadget for quick meals, crispy textures, and convenient cooking. Their promise of “fried results with little to no oil” has made them kitchen staples, especially for busy households. But as their popularity skyrockets, many home cooks have begun substituting their traditional ovens entirely — a trend that experts now warn could have unintended consequences, especially when preparing certain recipes.
Why People Are Replacing Ovens With Air Fryers
Air fryers offer speed and efficiency. They can reheat leftovers in minutes, crisp vegetables beautifully, and make weeknight dinners feel effortless. For small batches and quick cravings, they truly shine. But their strengths can also mislead users into thinking they’re a universal replacement for ovens — which they aren’t.
Cooking Capacity Remains Limited
While an oven can handle full baking sheets and large dishes, air fryers are confined to a much smaller basket or tray. Recipes that rely on spreading ingredients evenly — like roasted vegetables, baked chicken thighs, cookies, or sheet-pan dinners — can turn out uneven or soggy when crammed into an air fryer. Experts emphasize that overcrowding not only affects taste and texture but may also pose a food-safety risk by preventing proper heating.
Texture and Moisture Levels Can Change Recipes
Air fryers use rapid air circulation, which can dry out delicate dishes. Baked goods such as cakes, breads, casseroles, and pastries depend on controlled, even heating—something ovens accomplish far better than air fryers. Many recipes that perform beautifully in ovens can fail in the air fryer, resulting in:
Hard or over-browned exteriors
Undercooked centers
Collapsed cakes or breads
Overly dry meats
This is why experts suggest sticking to the oven for items that require gentle, uniform heat.
Not All Cookware Is Air-Fryer Safe
Another growing concern is the use of the wrong containers and tools inside air fryers. Unlike ovens, which can safely accommodate a range of cookware, many air fryers cannot handle:
Glass dishes
Certain nonstick pans
Silicone molds not rated for high airflow
Oversized metal trays
Using the wrong tools can damage the appliance — or worse, create a fire hazard.
Some Recipes Need the Oven’s Precision
Air fryers excel at certain recipes, but they struggle with others that ovens handle effortlessly:
Best for Air Fryers:
French fries and roasted potatoes
Chicken wings
Frozen snacks (nuggets, mozzarella sticks)
Roasted chickpeas
Small portions of vegetables
Toasted sandwiches
Quick reheating
Best for Ovens:
Lasagna, casseroles, and baked pasta
Cakes, breads, muffins, and pastries
Roasts and whole poultry
Sheet-pan meals
Slow-cooked dishes
ADVERTISEMENT
